On Saturday I hosted a cookie and tree trimming party. It was nearly ruined because I stayed out so late the night before at the Roundarch holiday party and I felt so sick on Saturday morning. It didn’t help that I got a call at 8:30 a.m. from our developer saying that the tile contractor was outside my door. Surprise! OMG. So, no sleep and a hangover. Luckily, my mom and my aunt Sue got to my house early and helped me clean and make appetizers and get everything ready. Otherwise, I’d have been laying there moaning on the couch unshowered in the middle of my messy house when my guests arrived. I could barely eat a cracker that my mom forced me to eat. I was so mad at myself for being such an idiot the night before. Luckily around 1 p.m. or so when everyone arrived at the party I started feeling better. I was so afraid I wouldn’t be able to eat cookies at the cookie party, but it all worked out fine. I owe my mom and my aunt big time!
Anyway, on to the party – many of my friends and family came over and each brought a few dozen cookies. We laid all of the cookies out and sampled them over the course of a few hours.

Front: Amanda, Caroline, Jessica, Rachelle, Cory, Auntie Glenna, Auntie Laura
Back: Auntie Gail, Aunt Sue, Tessa, Kelly, Stephanie, Jill, Heather, Jen, Jessica
Not pictured: Mom, Kate

Dallas’ Family: Auntie Laura, Cousin Heather, Auntie Glenna, Cousin Cory, Cousin (sort of) Caroline, Auntie Gail

Cookies!

Jess & Kate
I also served a cheese plate and a mix of crackers, Lit’l Smokies (cooked in chili sauce and grape jelly – don’t knock it til you try it!), and tortilla wraps to counter-balance all the sweets. To drink we had hot apple cider (spiked or not) which I still make from Julene’s Chicagoist recipe.

Rachelle & Cory

Jen & Jill

Aunt Sue helping out the whole time (thanks!)
We passed time talking and eating. Tessa and Jess were playing around and so cute, they were sources of entertainment. Jess and Tessa had fun trimming the tree (I’ll have separate posts on that). I had “It’s a Wonderful Life” playing on the TV. Most people know that movie by heart, so I just played holiday music while the movie was muted. Last year I commented on how I only took a few photos of the cookies and didn’t take any photos of people. This year Stephanie was using my camera and really getting into it. I was helping to give her tips on basic photography like how to frame photos better and what to take photos of. She did a really good job and this year we have a ton of photos of the party. There will be several posts after this one.

Stephanie

Rachelle & Stephanie

More Cookies!
These are all the tasty treats we sampled:
- Buckeyes (Jill)
- Caramel Filled Chocolate Cookies (Amanda)
- Cashew Toffee Bars (Rachelle)
- Chewy Chocolate Peppermint Cookies (Heather)
- Chocolate Covered Shortbread (Cory)
- Cinnamon & Sugar Cookies (Auntie Glenna)
- Coconut Joys (Mary/Mom)
- Emma Cookies – cherries, chocolate chips, oatmeal (Jen)
- Gingerbread Cookies (Rachelle)
- Macadamia Cookies (Aunt Sue)
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookies (Aunt Sue)
- Oatmeal Carmelita (Jess)
- Peanut Butter Blossoms (Auntie Laura)
- Peanut Butter Cookies (Auntie Gail)
- Peanut Butter Cracker Dips (Mary/Mom)
- Polish Cookies (Kelly)
- Pumpkin Chip Cookies (Amanda)
- Raspberry Cream Cheese Thumbprints (Amanda)
- Rum Balls (Kelly)
- Toffee Bars (Kate)
- White Chocolate Covered Cranberries (Mary/Mom)
- Wreath Cookies (Caroline)
The votes were really close last year so this year we did the voting a little differently. Instead of writing down the cookie you like best, everyone ranked their top 3 cookies. Steph and I tallied up the votes by giving a 1st place vote 5 points, a 2nd place vote 3 points and a 3rd place vote 1 point.

Jill carefully making her vote

Amanda helping Jess vote. Jess is pointing at her favorite cookie (the wreaths)

Some suspicious votes. Handwriting analysis is needed.

Vote tally
The results? In 3rd place were Jen’s Emma Cookies. In 2nd place was Jill’s Buckeyes. And the winner was Heather’s Chewy Chocolate Peppermint Cookies. For winning Heather got a holiday spatula and oven mitt as well as Marth Stewart’s cookie cookbook.

Tessa helping Heather open her gift

Heather, Tessa, Jessica

Heather’s gifts
I think my cookie party was a success. It seemed like everyone had a great time. I’m already looking forward to next year’s party!
- Photos from the 1st Annual Cookie and Tree Trimming Party
































